New Zealand’s agriculture has a strong co-operative tradition. Most of the country’s farmers are associated with more than one co-op, and 95% of the country’s fertiliser is sourced via farmer-owned co-ops – a fact that came into focus earlier this year when the crisis in the Strait of Hormuz disrupted global fertiliser markets.
“New Zealand is heavily exposed to those international supply chains. Our agricultural and horticultural sectors rely on a steady supply of nutrients sourced from around the world and, as a geographically remote nation, we sit a long way from many of the major production hubs,” writes Saya Wahrlich, CEO of Cooperative Business New Zealand.
“Yet while prices became volatile, supply to New Zealand farmers remained relatively secure,” she adds, drawing comparisons with Australia, which was left more exposed to this year’s disruption following a decades-long process of demutualisation of its own fertiliser co-ops.
Over roughly the same time period, New Zealand was instead building a nationwide network of more than 90 storage facilities via its farmer-owned co-ops, Ballance Agri-Nutrients and Ravensdown, capable of holding up to 25% of New Zealand’s annual fertiliser requirements.
“This long-term investment provides supply-chain resilience that private companies would struggle to replicate, ensuring farmers have access to product when they need it most,” she adds. “Both co-operatives are strengthening supply resilience through domestic manufacturing, diversified international sourcing, planning and increased inventory ahead of spring to protect supply during a period of extraordinary market volatility.”
Ballance CEO, Kelvin Wickham, highlighted inventory as a clear example of how its ownership structure impacted how it managed risk this year.
“We went into spring carrying more product than we normally would, and that lifted our borrowings at year end. This carries a cost, and a business answering to outside investors might have made a different call. Our owners are the same people who need that product on farm in September, so carrying it on their behalf was the right decision for them. It also means our shareholders can keep their money in their pocket and the fertiliser dry in our sheds until they need it.”
Writing in Rural News, Ravensdown director Dr Jacqueline Rowarth asserts that New Zealand’s co-operatives enable them to compete in world markets, as well as give its 5.3 million citizens “a voice in world trade”.
“It is the co-operatives that have been keeping the supply chains functioning in this era of international trade becoming both more expensive and important. They do this through the relationships they hold with companies overseas.”
“The co-operatives have built up assets and services in a manner that has not generally been copied by non-co-operative companies. Whether selling or buying, size leads to economies of scale and reliability, and makes the difference.”
Despite the clear benefits, Rowarth also tells Co-op News: “It’s quite difficult to be a co-operative.”
“Fly-by-nights, independents, come in and try and undercut. ….. For a co-operative, it’s trying to balance the security of supply with the survival of a company and the survival of the farmers. Whereas a fly-by-night does not mind about that last bit.”
A combination of gas supply issues and disruptive weather events have also created major challenges for New Zealand’s wider food system, explains Wahrlich.
“Although we are a food-producing nation, we don’t necessarily have food security or food resilience ourselves because of all of these converging factors. It’s resulting in growers closing because the cost of heating the glasshouse puts the food price up too much. So larger growers are surviving, smaller ones aren’t necessarily, and it’s a real crisis. Once that food production base is gone, getting it back is near impossible because you’ve lost infrastructure, you’ve lost skills, you’ve lost all that production power.”
While New Zealand’s fertiliser story demonstrates how co-operation can buffer some of these shocks, awareness and understanding of the sector remains a challenge for the country’s co-ops, says Rowarth.
“What’s been happening over the generations is that family loyalty is not as great, and the way we have brought up the younger generations is to think ‘it’s a great big scary world out there. You’ve got to be strong and make your case’ – and that has implications for the co-operatives.”
In her article, Wahrlich acknowledges the strength of New Zealand’s self-image based around the symbol of the No. 8 wire – a material historically repurposed by the country’s farmers with limited access to alternatives – which has come to represent the country’s resourcefulness and resulting innovation.
“It’s a story we’ve become good at telling, particularly when positioning New Zealand businesses internationally. But there is another response to many of those same constraints that features far less often in our national story. New Zealanders also co-operated,” writes Wahrlich, who is now working to nurture a complimentary story of New Zealand’s co-operative spirit alongside its more established one of isolated ingenuity.
Rowarth is doing the same, as she stresses:
“Co-ops have also been more resilient through economic recessions. And war. As the disruption of the supply chains starts affecting the smaller players it is the strength of the co-operatives and the farmers that belong, that will keep the economy humming. Members of a co-operative do together what no person can do alone.”

